On a sunny Friday afternoon in June I found myself driving to western Ohio to attend Band Camp X, the 10th Annual
Pittsburgh Vintage Scooter Club Camping Rally. My boyfriend, a member of the club, had convinced me to go despite my lack of love for beer (yucky) and scooters (scary), the main features of the rally. I wasn't sure what to expect, but a cake from
Charm City Cakes wasn't on the list.
It turns out that Mary Smith, one of the decorators in the bakery/
on the show, is a scooterist and had come to the rally. She'd decorated the cake herself and brought it as a gift.
The cake was squirreled away until the last night of the rally when it was presented to the crowd after dinner. Agonizingly, the cake was on display until after midnight, when it was finally cut and served to a crowd half-crazed from anticipation. (Ok, maybe that was just me.)
I'll be honest. I fully expected this cake to taste like total crap. I've seen the show – cakes are baked at least two days prior to delivery, and are stored in a ginormous refrigerator until they're decorated. Assuming the cake is made without preservatives, the refrigeration process should dry it out and mute the flavor. Combine that with the fact that the completed cake was stored in the back of a barn for three days until it was served, and I didn't think it had a snowball's chance in hell of tasting good.
You can imagine my shock when I took my first bite and discovered that the cake was
moist. (Perhaps the gumpaste sides sealed the cake, locking in the moisture? Or maybe the cake was made with preservatives?) Not only was the at least-four-day-old cake still moist, but the flavor wasn't half bad. Rich, buttery, and slightly sweet – a perfectly fine vanilla cake. The frosting was peanut butter flavored, and had both the taste and texture of crunchy peanut butter with a tiny bit of powered sugar added for sweetness. A bit odd, especially paired with a vanilla cake, but not untasty. The gumpaste tasted like gumpaste – chewy, sweet, and flavorless, but I doubt anyone really expects it to be eaten. Surprisingly, the strange flavor pairing turned out to be my biggest complaint about the cake. Crazy!
So yeah, if you ever get the opportunity to try a cake from Charm City Cakes, do it! Their "edible art" turned out to be way more edible than I'd assumed.